Get answers to your dating questions or leave comments here! Email me with your dating dilemmas, and I'll publish my replies here.

To get updates when new blogs are posted, sign up for the newsletter!

Your Live-in Boyfriend Wants an Open Relationship: Now What?

Why is she never the oneDear Annie, I’ve been living with Jerry for six months. He just told me that he wants to open up our relationship so we can have sex with others. I’m deeply hurt. Although I was aware that he had been in polyamorous relationships in the past, he told me that he was fine with our relationship being one hundred percent monogamous.

Now he insists that it is unnatural and unrealistic for men and women to be sexually monogamous. He says he loves me and needs me to be his primary emotional relationship, but that he craves sex with other women or he doesn’t feel like a whole man.

He tells me that I’m being selfish, disloyal and unreasonable because I don’t want to step out of the bounds of our monogamous relationship.

I love him. But, it doesn’t feel as if this feeling is truly mutual. His desire for intimacy with others leaves me feeling terribly insecure.

I told him that I don’t think I can stay in our relationship if he starts sleeping with other women. He says that I am being unreasonable and I have no reason to feel jealous. I still don’t feel comfortable about it.

We are at an impasse. What do I do? Lucille

I can see why you feel betrayed. You entered into a relationship under one set of agreements and assumptions and suddenly your partner is demanding that you do something that he knows is unacceptable to you.

It sounds like Jerry made you a promise that he couldn’t keep. Although he previously enjoyed being in open relationships, he thought that he could forsake them because he wanted to be with you. Unfortunately, he revisited his priorities after the two of you established a household together. This leaves you with two difficult options.

Option one is to draw a line in the sand and walk away without looking back. You have to be firm and unwavering. It’s not about playing a game of pretending to leave, and hoping that he will change his mind.

Tell him that you must break up because cannot tolerate being in an open relationship. If he tells you that you’re being unreasonable, let him know that it is about honoring your values and that this is something about which you are unable to compromise.

Give him notice, and start packing your boxes and looking for a new place to live.

Option two is to be open to researching the different types of open relationships and exploring the possibility that there may be a way to allow other sexual partners into your relationship in a way that would also allow you to feel safe.

In that case, you and Jerry should to set firm parameters around how that relationship would work and negotiate an agreement that is mutually acceptable to both of you.

If you did so, both of you would need to agree on the following:

  • Timing: When, for how long and how often can each of you go on a “date.”
  • Duration: You may want to restrict the amount of dates that each of you can have with another person in order to minimize the possibility of becoming emotionally involved.
  • Activity: You can limit the type of sexual activity that happens between your partner and someone else.
  • Conditions: You could only allow it under certain circumstances, such as when he’s on a business trip.

Sex columnist Dan Savage has many more suggestions for how to negotiate an open relationship.

However, if being in an open relationship leaves you feeling as if it will make you miserable or drain the life out of you, just say no and leave.

The most fundamental problem you’re facing isn’t simply whether you can accept a form of open relationship. The bottom line is that you’ve discovered that you can’t rely on Jerry to be true to his word.

Continue reading
140 Hits

The Perils of Sharing Your Sexual Secrets Over Text Message

Flirt over white wine.1Dear Annie, Kevin texted me that he enjoys cross-dressing during sex right after our third date. I was taken aback. We’ve only kissed a little and now he’s texting me about his sexual preferences. Ugh.

I like him and was looking forward to seeing him again, but I don’t understand why he wouldn’t share intimate information like this during an in-person conversation. Getting a text like this feels cold, clinical and impersonal.

I was excited about the prospect of us gradually becoming physically and emotionally closer, but now I’m not sure. I’ve never been with a man who enjoys wearing women’s clothes in bed (or out.)

Frankly, the idea turns me off. But, I might have a different attitude if someone I cared for wanted to experiment. I told him I wasn’t interested. Did I do the right thing or should I have been more open? Elaine

The short answer is that you don’t need to be open to everything.

I wonder if you were more put off by the fact that he enjoys cross-dressing or by the way that he communicated it. Texting is a medium where the person’s tone of voice and emotional response isn’t present.

The juxtaposition between the cold, tone-deafness of a text message and the intimacy of the topic might have caused you to feel uninterested in moving forward with the relationship. You may have gotten the message that he seems to be more comfortable talking about intimate topics over text messages than doing so in person.

His method and timing of sharing this information were not designed in a way that would encourage you to be open to the possibility of enjoying his kink. Things might have worked out differently if Kevin had waited until you were in a more intimate phase of the relationship before he revealed this secret.

You might have been more open to the possibility of cross-dressing if he was able to communicate his interest in it in a loving, caring way that caused you to want to please him.

Kevin didn’t ask for my advice, but if he had, this is what I would have told him:

You’re more likely to elicit a positive response if you establish an intimate relationship before you talk about sensitive sexual needs in person. Usually this happens somewhere between the third and sixth date.

Bring up the topic late in a date if things are going well.

Tell your date a little bit about your kink and what it provides. Ask if they have any questions. Allow your date time as much time as needed to think about whether this is something to which they feel open. 

Texting is the one of the riskiest way to divulge personal information. It can feel abrupt and it’s easy for the recipient to misinterpret the sender’s intentions. Conversations about sex, whether they are about STDs, sexual fetishes or preferences are likely to be better received when they are communicated in person.

Continue reading
358 Hits

How to Talk to Your Boyfriend About His Porn Addiction

Man with LaptopDear Annie, How can I tell whether Jeff, my boyfriend, simply likes porn or is addicted to it? He watches it almost every day. He says that there is nothing wrong with it and that I should accept it as part of a normal, healthy man’s sex life these days.

I feel ashamed, but I’m really insecure about it. While I’m pretty attractive for a forty-six year old woman, I can’t compete with the very agile, young and curvy women that he sees on a daily basis. I think that it’s also giving him ideas about the kind of sex acts we should engage in. He’s been putting me under a lot of pressure to have anal sex, even though that doesn’t interest me. In fact, it grosses me out. I really don’t want to come across as judgmental and critical. How do I deal with his porn habits? Linda

Before getting into the porn aspect, I want to address your insecurities around other women. It’s easy to forget that one of your assets is that you are actually present for your partner. The women you’re worried about are unattainable.

It’s best not to perceive other women as competition. There will always be a woman who is more beautiful, more enchanting and seems as if she might be more desirable. If you view another women as a threat to your relationship, you are diminishing your sense of your own worth. Jeff loves you for his own reasons, and you must trust that this is enough.

In my close to a decade as a dating coach, I have been thoroughly convinced that the intensity of the male sex drive is almost impossible for most women to understand.

Jeff, like any normal man, is bound to be attracted to numerous women. His desire for sex has little, more likely nothing, to do with his desire for a relationship with any of them. He needs to be sexually attracted and emotionally connected in order to be in a relationship.

Regarding porn: I’m not going to get into the political thicket of it–that’s another column or even a book. However porn is so widely accepted and available at this moment that many men are drawn to partake. But, just because Jeff indulges in it doesn’t mean that he needs to share the details with you.

Tell him that, from now, on you would prefer that his porn habits become private. Ask him to refrain from sharing all the details. Tell him that it is not something that you wish to hear about. If he has been watching porn when you are present, ask him to stop doing so because it isn’t a shared pleasurable activity.

If he wants to try a porn-inspired sexual activity, request that he communicate his desire as if it was something that he thought of on his own. Then you can decide whether it’s something that you might want to try.

If not, decline. It’s okay to not want to try a specific sexual act. Whatever you do, don’t feel like you have to be a porn star in bed in order to please Jeff. All you need to do is be open, responsive and enthusiastic.

One of my concerns about porn is that it sends the message that your performance in bed is more important than your connection in real life. As long as Jeff is making love with you, then I suggest you allow him the space and privacy to enjoy other parts of his sexuality without offending you.

Continue reading
556 Hits

Can You Ever Trust a Boyfriend Who Lied About Herpes?

Romantic midlife coupleDear Annie, I just discovered that my boyfriend, Rich, has genital herpes. We have been sleeping together for almost a year! We were tested before we became intimate. He told me that his results were negative and it didn’t occur to me that I needed to look at the actual report.

I feel incredibly betrayed that he lied to me. He says that he wasn’t brave enough to tell me because he was so worried about losing me. At this point, I don’t feel that I can trust him any more.

To my knowledge, he hasn’t lied about anything else. But, this is big. He risked my health! Is this something that is worth my breaking up with him? Beth

Some people—especially those who are insecure—may be tempted to hide the truth about something that might seem shameful if they think they can get away with it.

The problem is that his lie has possible long-term consequences, and his disregard for this potential outcome reveals his selfish side. He purposely did not allow you to make the choice of whether you wanted to take the risk of contracting the disease.

On the other hand, herpes is a highly stigmatized, yet very common disease. This makes it unusually difficult to discuss. Estimates vary, but according to the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention about one in six adults in the US between the ages of 14 to 49 has herpes. Many are silent carriers who don’t even know that they have it.

Rich’s fear of telling you is understandable. He didn’t want to lose you. However, he betrayed you by not revealing the truth.

While deception is valid grounds for ending a relationship, you might want to consider whether this is a one-time incident or part of a pattern. This is not an excuse, but being infected with herpes carries a huge stigma, and many of those afflicted agonize over how and when to reveal it to potential romantic partners.

Not everyone is brave enough to broach the topic at an appropriate time. They may believe that they can’t transmit the virus if they are careful. The problem is that they neglect to provide their partner the opportunity to assess risk and make a decision for themselves.

In deciding whether you want to leave him, I suggest that you look back and consider whether he has been otherwise honest and ethical in his dealings with you and others. If that is the case, I suggest that you consider giving him another chance. But if you find that he has a continuous tendency to twist things to his own advantage, you might want to cut your losses.

If you leave and discover that you have contracted herpes, I suggest this is how you approach telling your future partners.

  • Plan to inform your date at a neutral time in an environment that is not sexually charged
  • Say that you have something important to talk about. Be prepared for any type of response
  • Say that you, like one sixth of the population, have been infected with herpes. Your date may be in the same situation. If he is not, provide the following information:
    • Give him details so that he can assess risk potential: how long have you been infected? How often do you have outbreaks? Have you ever transmitted it to anyone?
    • Tell him whether you’re willing to take antivirals in order to mitigate your risk of transmission
    • Give him the name of a reliable website so that he can do some research
    • Allow him to make a decision at his own pace.

    One of the biggest problems with herpes is the shame and stigma that surrounds it. If you know how to clearly, calmly and honestly discuss it, you won’t have to risk revealing a secret that could unravel your relationship at a later date.

Continue reading
616 Hits

Commitment Mystery: How to Understand His Intentions

Affectionate couple relaxDear Annie, What does a man mean when he says that he wants to be in a committed relationship? John told me that he wanted to be in a committed relationship before we slept together on our third date.

I didn’t hear much from him after that. When I called, he said that he was busy with a work project. I was flabbergasted when I ran into him in in the mall a week later. He was holding hands with another woman! When I got the opportunity to ask him about it, he said that we were only in a committed relationship for the night we were together.

I was speechless! I thought that being in a committed relationship meant that we would continue dating exclusively and see where it goes. Now I’m not sure. How can I tell whether I can trust someone? Jane

John probably knew that you weren’t going to allow him to have sex unless he told you he wanted to be involved in a committed relationship. He may have even thought it was a good idea at the time, but changed his mind after he satisfied his sexual desire.

While many women agree on the definitions of the words “exclusive” and “committed,” men vary in their interpretations. I learned this early in 2009, when I gave a co-ed dating class and asked how many participants wanted a commitment before they would engage in sex.

One of the men asked how long that kind of commitment should last. “Just that night? For the next week or month?” I couldn’t believe my ears. As a woman, the meaning of the word seems obvious. Clearly, that doesn’t translate the same way to all men,

That is when I learned that it’s one of the many areas where it’s important that the person who wants commitment to protect herself by having a discussion about what she must have in a relationship, especially one that includes sex. It’s incumbent on her withhold intimacy until he’s demonstrated that he’s willing to provide what she needs. (The same goes for a man in a similar situation.)

Have this conversation in a non-sexually charged situation so that he’s not under the impression that a correct answer will immediately get his sexual needs met.

First, you should find out what level of commitment he wants. Ask what he would expect each of your roles to look like should you become more intimate. Discuss what your expectations and hopes would be if you move forward.

Does being committed or exclusive mean that either of you are still open to being in a relationship with someone else if a different opportunity presents itself? Does it mean that you’re only seeing each other while exploring the possibility of a relationship with a future?

It’s OK to tell him what you need. The only men you will scare away are those who aren’t interested in a relationship—and you are better off if you eliminate them early on.

It’s also unreasonable to believe that you know each other well enough to commit to each other until you’ve spent significant time together—far more than just three dates.

Continue reading
802 Hits

7 Signs You Might be Dating a Sociopath

Traveling coupleDear Annie, Ralph, my boyfriend of two years, is always having some sort of emergency. He’s a good man: loving and kind, but it’s been a while since he’s been able to pay his own way. 

When we met, he was charming, generous and fun. Our romance was spectacular. He even took me to the Caribbean after we had only known each other for a few months.

He was initially a fantastic partner. He took care of things around the house and was a delightful companion. I have never felt more connected to anyone. He was completely supportive in a thoughtful and attentive manner.

Although he remained somewhat physically affectionate, he began to withdraw after a few months and started criticizing my body. We stopped having full-on sex. He told me that he loved me, yet he wanted me to commit to being best friends for life if our relationship didn’t work out.

I never completely understood what he did for living. He was in business with several partners, most of whom I never met. He owned a luxurious custom-designed home with lovely views in another state. When I visited, I thought it was rather odd that he had a roommate who dominated the house. However in a way, it made sense because Ralph was rarely there.

After we were together for six months or so, his business had a sudden downturn and he fell behind on his house payments. It went into foreclosure. He started borrowing money from his sister and discovered that the best way to save his house was to declare bankruptcy. Since he was living with me most of the time, I thought that it might be nicer not to ask him to pay for groceries when he was under such financial stress.

He had one perplexing crisis after another. Each situation made me feel sorry for him. I wanted to be a good partner. He ended up owing me several thousand dollars before I got suspicious. I reluctantly started snooping, which I have never done before.

When I insisted that he pay his way and contribute $100 a month towards his living expenses debt, he reluctantly agreed. Suddenly, he had to go on many more business trips than before.

I hired a private investigator to figure out what was going on. I discovered that he had history of owing friends money; it amounts to tens of thousands of dollars to date. I also discovered that his house was not in foreclosure.

I’m completely confused. I have no idea what, if anything, he told me was true. When I confronted him he was angry and told me that I had no business spying on him. He accused me of being disloyal and told me that my past romances have failed because I’m unable to be a real partner.

When I try to break it off he says that he still loves and needs me. He promises he will do better; that this is just a temporary situation and that things will be better as soon as various difficulties have been solved. He asked me to stand by him and that his life won’t be worth living if we break up.

He has started to pay his way, even though sometimes he pays with a postdated check. But he has yet to put a real dent in the thousands of dollars he owes me.

I love him. But, I’m not sure that I can trust him. He treats me very well when he’s here, but when he’s away, which is most of the time, he barely has time to talk on the phone. What do I do? Francesca

You sound like you have lost faith in your own perceptions. Rather than expecting Ralph’s values to be aligned with yours, you’re trying to rationalize why he would behave in this way. Your belief that he has good intentions has made it possible for you to ignore the way his actions are impacting you.

If you can’t identify with the way that your partner approaches life, it’s time to question whether this is a viable relationship.

When someone is incredibly charming at first glance, but his later behavior scares or confuses you, you may have a sociopath on your hands. A sociopath doesn’t have a conscience—it’s all about them. They don’t believe that the normal rules that bind others—such as repaying loans or earning money at real job—apply to them either.

They don’t question how what they do affects others. They only wonder why they didn’t get what they wanted at the time.

They are experts at charming people in order to get what they want. The understand how to make people feel special and to generally be perceived as fun, likable and interesting. Identifying a sociopath takes time and getting to know them well, without making excuses for their behavior.

According to sociopath expert Martha Stout, PHD, the author of The Sociopath Next Door, “When deciding who to trust, bear in mind that the combination of consistently bad or egregiously inadequate behavior with frequent plays for your pity is as close to a warning. ... as you will ever be given.”

Stout cites following as a partial list of the signs that someone may be a sociopath:

  1. Glibness and superficial charm: They are engaging, likable and fun to be around.
  2. Lack of a realistic life plan and a parasitic lifestyle: They tend to move a lot or make all-encompassing promises for the future. They have a poor work ethic but are able to effectively exploit others.
  3. Lack of concern about wrecking others' lives and dreams: They are oblivious or indifferent to the devastation they cause. They do not accept blame themselves, only others, even for acts they obviously committed.
  4. Manipulative and conning: They don’t recognize the rights of others and see their self-serving behaviors as permissible. They appear to be charming, yet see their victim as merely an instrument to be used.
  5. Grandiose sense of self: They feel entitled to certain things, such as others paying their way, as "their right."
  6. Pathological lying: They have no problem lying and it is almost impossible for them to be consistently truthful. They can create--and get caught up in--their own powers and abilities. Their lies are extremely convincing and most are even able to pass lie detector tests.
  7. Lack of remorse, shame or guilt: They do not see others around them as people, but only as targets and opportunities. Instead of friends, they have victims and accomplices who end up as victims. They believe that the end always justifies the means and they let nothing stand in their way.

It sounds like Ralph’s behavior matches some of these criteria. The most important thing you can do is to take steps to protect yourself. Because you can’t reason with a sociopath, your best bet is to accept your losses and completely cut him out of your life.

Continue reading
850 Hits

Trust but Verify: How to Discover Whether He's Actually Married

Red wine date last minuteDear Annie, The last three men I dated told me that they were single, but I later found out that all of them were married! I’m a 57 year-old, single woman who wants to be in a relationship. I went online to meet single, divorced or widowed men near my age. 

I dated one of these guys for almost three months before I found out that his wife was alive and well. I was crushed, as we had gotten along wonderfully and I was beginning to think that we might have a future together.

I discovered that he was married when I ran into them at the dog park. When I saw him, I kissed him hello and he ignored me. She put her arm around his waist and he put his around her shoulder. That was completely humiliating! He called later and told me that his marriage has not been working for a long time.

He said that he and his current wife live separate lives and begged me to continue our relationship. After a lot of soul-searching, I reluctantly decided to stop seeing him. After all, what are they doing together in the dog park if their lives are so separate?

I decided that the online dating scene is not great for me. I don’t feel like I can trust anyone online, so I have decided to go a different route and try to meet through a mutual connection.

I have asked some people I know to introduce me to their single male friends. I have two upcoming blind dates.

Why do men lie about their marital status? Coral

Meeting men in person is a great way to go, especially if your friends can make introductions.

Online dating is just another way to meet people. All it does is introduce you to men who have described themselves by answering some questions and posting a few photos. It favors those whose photos are engaging, write well and who understand how to best use a particular site.

One of the problems with online dating is that it’s easy to get the impression that you can make assumptions about someone’s character and relationship potential from information gleaned from reading a profile and a handful of email correspondence. But, in reality, the only way you can find out about someone is to meet him in person as quickly as possible and take it from there.

I suggest that you approach getting to know a new man in the same way as you would if you met a gentleman at a bar. Ask lots of questions. Verify his answers. Observe how he behaves over time. Find out how he thinks, what he values and what his life has been like until you met. This is a "buyer beware" situation.

The same is true when you meet someone through a friend. Your friend can't possibly know how the person to whom they introduce you handles love and romance. They can't possibly know whether you'll click in the long term.

In either case, I suggest that you always take the following steps when you meet someone new, whether your introduction originated online or in real life.

  1. Ask for his last name and other identifying information. It makes no sense to go out with someone without having such basic information. You are not prying when you ask for a man’s name, address and place of employment. That is information that you’re entitled to if you’re going to go out with him. If he’s reluctant to provide it, consider it a red flag.
  2.  Look him up on the Internet. Take it a step further than just Googling him. Search on sites like Zabasearch.com, Spokeo or Zillow, which provide homeowner information. If his home has a woman on the title, you should investigate further. It could be innocent – he might have his daughter or ex-wife on the deed. Or, it could be his current wife.
  3. Many work or social media bios provide good information. Take a look at the website at his place of employment, LinkedIn or Facebook profile. While it’s not unheard of for someone to create a false social media profile, this information should corroborate with other research that you may have done.
  4. If he is widowed, find out when his wife died. Ask for her name and Google death notices to make sure she is actually dead. One of my clients became suspicious when her widowed date was reluctant to have her over to his home. It turned out that the man’s wife was very much alive. It's why I recommend that you see a man's home before the fourth date and definitely do so before becoming emotionally entangled. A married man is likely to bolt before allowing you anywhere near his home.
  5. Technology has made cheating on one’s spouse easier than in years past. All family mail used to arrive in the same mailbox. Families shared phone lines. But, the advent of separate cell phone numbers and email addresses has made it very easy for a married person to have a secret life.

All kinds of men are looking to meet women, in person and online. Many are ethical and seeking relationships. Some are not. The best way to proceed is to prioritize discovering who the other person is while you take your time becoming involved with someone you don't really know.

Continue reading
822 Hits

The Art of Approaching an Interesting Woman

Hi Annie, I often see interesting women at the grocery store and gym, but I’m hesitant to start a conversation for fear of intruding upon their privacy.

What is a woman’s point of view on being approached when she’s out and about? Is there any way I can introduce myself without making women feel uncomfortable? Ron

Introducing yourself to a stranger requires courage. It helps if you can appear casual and self-assured, even if you’re not feeling that way. Take a few deep breaths and go for it!

There is no guarantee that you’re not going to offend a particular woman. Each woman is going to respond in her own unique way. You can’t fault yourself for making an effort if you express yourself in a respectful, polite and friendly way.

Consider other factors, such as time of day, what she’s doing and location. Obviously, there is a big difference between approaching women at a grocery store or gym in broad daylight and saying hello when you encounter her in a dark street.
Your best bet is to approach someone when she’s not focused on accomplishing something. Say hello when she’s walking, sitting down or waiting in line. You’ll quickly discover if she’s open to a casual, lighthearted chat.

Women who are unavailable will often let you know in the course of a short conversation. Otherwise, you can find out if she’s single by complimenting something she’s wearing and asking if her husband gave it to her. If she says that she’s not married, ask if it is from her boyfriend.

If she’s single, tell her that you’d like to get to know her a little bit better at a more convenient time and offer her your phone number. She’s more likely to respond positively if you do this in a friendly, open manner.

It helps if you know what to say to a woman who is unavailable. You could tell her that her significant other is a lucky guy or ask her how they met.
I suggest that you practice chatting with new women as often as possible. You’re likely to find that the vast majority of them are open to a brief conversation. You can’t predict how some women will react. The right woman might be happy that you made the first move.

Continue reading
901 Hits

Sign up to receive my free gift: 10 Steps to Take to Revolutionize Your Love Life Now!

Most dating advice you’ve read is wrong. Let me show you what’s right. Multiple Streams of Dating Interest is a power-packed 3-page PDF I created specifically for you. Now you can stop listening to “tips” that don’t work and start strategically increasing your opportunities to meet someone worthwhile.

You’ll also receive tips and advice about the most effective way to date in the 21st century. You will never receive spam.